Woman Says Grandmother Left Her Jewelry When She Died, But Cousin Claims It Should Be Hers
"She’s even told everyone that my grandmother’s decision must have been a mistake or made under pressure," the woman wrote in a Reddit post
simon2579/Getty/Stock Image
Stock photo of a women's hand holding a golden ringAfter their grandmother's death, two cousins are arguing over who is the rightful owner of their loved one's bling — and it's dividing the whole family.
In a recent "Am I the A------?" post on Reddit, a 24-year-old woman stated that her grandmother, who died last year, left her a "beautiful jewelry collection in her will."
"Growing up, I was very close to her, and we spent countless weekends together where she would let me try on her pieces," she wrote. "It always felt like our little thing, so when she left them to me, I was deeply touched."
However, her 28-year-old cousin — "let's call her Emma," the Redditor wrote — claims that their grandmother had “verbally promised her the collection years ago."
"Even though there's no mention of her in the will," the woman wrote that her cousin "claims that the jewelry is hers by right."
"She’s even told everyone that my grandmother’s decision must have been a mistake or made under pressure," the woman added.
The woman said that things heated up when her cousin called, "demanding I hand the jewelry over to 'honor' what she says was my grandmother’s real wish."
"When I said no, she called me selfish and accused me of stealing what was meant for her," she added.
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
Now, the woman said that the family is divided over what to do: some are "saying I should just give Emma a few pieces to keep the peace," while others insist that she hold her ground.
"I feel terrible because I don’t want to cause family drama, but I also believe my grandmother knew exactly what she was doing when she left the collection to me," the woman wrote, going on to ask her fellow Redditors what they thought.
Related: Woman Says She Refuses to Let Cousin Use Her Leftover College Fund Money: 'Not My Responsibility'
The comment section determined that the woman was "not an a--hole," with one person pointing out, "You are also following your grandmother's wishes, and, unlike your cousin, you have proof that's the case."
"Don't you dare disrespect your grandmother's will by handing her anything," added another commenter. "It's so easy for your family to say to give her some when it is not theirs to give."
Meanwhile, others sympathized with Emma and her strong feelings over the jewelry. "If your cousin really was promised the jewelry, then I get where she is coming from," read one reply.
Other commenters said that maybe the best path forward really was to just figure out a way to share.
"I know it is a set but who cares," read one reply. "It is sharing something that is sentimental of your grandmother's with also your cousin. You both must miss her a lot. Instead of fighting, which I may think your grandma would not like, share in the beautiful memories of her. It will connect you, your cousin and your grandmother together in a special way."
Read the original article on People
