Is it ever OK to leave your baby in the car alone?

Is it ever ok to leave a baby in a car alone? [Photo: Getty]
Is it ever ok to leave a baby in a car alone? [Photo: Getty]

A woman has sparked a parenting debate online about whether or not it is acceptable to leave your baby in a car alone while you drop an older child at preschool.

Taking to parenting site Mumsnet, the anonymous mum said that every morning when she drops her own three-year-old off at preschool she has noticed a baby left in a car on its own outside.

Though the mum points out that she understands how difficult it can be to do the drop off with a baby in tow, she herself takes her six-month-old out of his car seat and into the nursery with her.

“Sometimes the drop off can take 10 mins or more by the time you are buzzed in etc, especially if it’s busy and there’s a queue to get in the classroom,” she wrote.

“Car is parked right at the corner of a busy junction on double yellow lines – it’s a 2 min walk away. There’s no way she could see the baby as you have to go round the corner,” she continued.

“AIBU to think the baby shouldn’t be left in the car?”

The mum went on to explain that she’s so concerned she’s thinking of talking to the nursery manager, but her husband thinks she should “stay out of it”.

She finished her post by asking the forum what they thought about the thorny subject.

And other parents were quick to step in and offer their own opinions.

Many agreed with the mum that the baby shouldn’t be left in the car.

“Cars temperatures can rise rapidly on hot days, babies have a difference in fluid volumes to surface area than adults – they dehydrate much quicker. It can be bloody dangerous even just under 10 minutes,” one user wrote.

“Would you leave £1000 in cash on show in your car for 10 minutes? No? Then why on earth would you leave your baby?” another woman added.

“I wouldn’t do it, no,” another added. “Concerns about the baby being kidnapped or the car being hit are one thing, but the most likely is that the baby could get really upset – I would hate to think of my baby crying for 10 mins or so and nobody being there to soothe her.”

But other parents couldn’t see a problem with it.

“The baby was probably safer in the car than being taken with the parent,” one user suggested. “Officialdom in the UK is often ridiculous when it comes to enforcing safety.”

“To be honest it’s a stretch to say the baby is in danger isn’t it? The other mum has assessed the situation and is happy with it,” another mum added.

A woman has sparked a debate about whether it is ever ok to leave a baby in a car alone? [Photo: Getty]
A woman has sparked a debate about whether it is ever ok to leave a baby in a car alone? [Photo: Getty]

One mum said it was “no different to paying for petrol or nipping cash point.”

Before another added: “I wouldn’t get involved myself. I think it’s only illegal if it’s deemed as placing them in harms way.”

Some parents shared examples of times they have left their own children in the car.

“I’ve done it before with one child when dropping the other off at preschool when one or the other in the equation had chicken pox and there was only me to do the preschool run,” one mum wrote.

“I’ve left my twins in the car to run into a little co-op store for bread and milk but I could see the car at all times and checked there wasn’t a huge queue before committing so knew there would be no hold ups,” one mum shared.

“The thought of getting them both up and into the pushchair and then back in car seats and putting the double pushchair away seemed like an awful lot of faff for bread and milk.”

“I do this all the time,” another mum added. “Not every time, but if she’s asleep I don’t wake her, or if her chest’s bad (repeat bronchiolitis) and the weather’s inclement I leave her be. The preschool know. I’m happy with my decision,” another parent commented.

Whether or not to leave your children in the car while you nip to the shop/pay for the petrol/grab a quick caffeine hit is a dilemma many parents have faced.

Back in 2016, the subject prompted one mum to pen a post about the moment she confronted a mum who left her children in the car to get a takeaway coffee.

A number of other parenting debates have been ignited online recently.

Earlier this year Sam Faiers sparked a discussion on whether or not it is safe to diet while breastfeeding.

Last year Katy Hill got the Internet in a tizz after blasting a “negative and mean hearted” couple who disapproved of noisy children being in Pizza Express.

And back in November Cruz Beckham kicked-off a debate about how young is too young to be working out in the gym.

Follow us on Instagram and Facebook for non-stop inspiration delivered fresh to your feed, every day. For Twitter updates, follow @YahooStyleUK.

Read more from Yahoo Style UK:

Half of all mums keep post-natal depression and other maternal mental health issues secret

British parents are spending way less time helping their children with homework than in other countries

Would you use an app to name your baby?