An Expert Reveals Why Buttermilk Is The Secret To Deliciously Tangy Cheesecake - Exclusive

Jennifer Richmond
·2-min read
Slice of East Side Cheesecake's Ex New Yorker cheesecake
Slice of East Side Cheesecake's Ex New Yorker cheesecake - East Side Cheesecakes

When we think of cheesecake, images of rich and creamy deliciousness dance in our heads and we immediately start to drool. While we prefer a thick, luscious slice of the classic, no-frills, New York-style cheesecake, we'll happily indulge in any other flavor from chocolate to key lime. Seriously, as long as it has that impeccable combination of sweet and sour, we're all in. The only question is, how do you get that perfect blend? Will any old cream cheese work or do you need something special?

Since we don't have all the answers, we asked professional cheesecake bakers Julia Tokarz and Gregory Lay from L.A.'s Eastside Cheesecakes at the inaugural Los Angeles Wine & Food Festival what their secret is to the perfect cheesecake. We were sure it would be a full-fat cream cheese. Turns out we were wrong. It's actually buttermilk.

Buttermilk gives the cake "that nice creaminess," explains Tokarz. "And it also helps give it an extra tanginess to it." That tanginess comes from the fermentation that happens when bacterial cultures, salt, and citric acid are blended with skim milk, which produces the familiar sour flavor buttermilk is known for.

Read more: 30 Types Of Cake, Explained

Buttermilk-Based Cream Cheese Is Better Than Store-Bought

2 glasses of buttermilk
2 glasses of buttermilk - Fascinadora/Shutterstock

Cultured buttermilks tend to be more sour than the buttermilk created while making butter, but both have a distinct tang -- a tang that Lay says you won't find in most store-bought cream cheeses. "All other cheesecakes are made with store-bought, preservative-filled, sort of, you know, rubber, paste-like cream cheese," Lay says chuckling. "And it's amazing, you kind of forget that you're using actual cheese. So, when you make fresh cheese, it offers a whole other level of flavor or flavor profile as well as a creamier texture."

Lay made this discovery while working at a bagel shop that made its own cream cheese. The secret ingredient in said cream cheese? Buttermilk. But it wasn't until the pandemic hit that Tokarz decided to use Lay's cream cheese to make the perfect cheesecake. She'd just lost her job and wondered, "What if we use this cream cheese to make a cheesecake, cause nobody does that[?]" So, Tokarz took her final paycheck, bought a used mixer off Craigslist, pulled out her mom's Christmas cheesecake recipe, and Eastside Cheesecakes was born.

The couple believes their shop is a success because of that homemade, buttermilk-based cream cheese. "People that don't like cheesecake at all, love the cheesecake," Lay says. "And then the people that are lactose intolerant are willing to go with the pain in order to taste it. So, it really does change the entire thing. It's not as dense and it's full of flavor."

Read the original article on Tasting Table.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • How The Bombay Sandwich Outlived The Industry That (Likely) Spawned It

    The Bombay sandwich has been around for decades and is still going strong. The same can't really be said for the industry that probably birthed it.

  • The Rare Scandinavian Fruit That Dates Back To The Vikings

    Some fruit varieties have a history as storied as that of humanity itself. And one small, elusive Scandinavian fruit once eaten by the Vikings takes the cake.

  • What drinking coffee every morning does to your stomach

    That morning cup of coffee doesn’t just wake you up for the day, it also gives a boost to billions of friendly microbes residing in your digestive system. Because, according to a growing body of research, there is evidence that your espresso may positively influence your microbiome – gut bacteria – leading to better overall health and even a longer life.

  • Is It Safe To Eat Green Rhubarb?

    As rhubarb season quickly approaches, you might be eyeing the green rhubarb in your backyard and wondering if it's safe to eat. Here's what you need to know.

  • The celebrity-owned restaurant in London where guests are treated like royalty

    The thing about restaurants owned by celebrity chefs is that expectations, naturally, run high.

  • I Asked Chefs to Pick The Best Pasta Sauce and They All Chose This Brand

    There was one clear winner.

  • The 20 Best Chicken Thigh Recipes

    You'll want to make them on repeat.

  • The Unexpected 3-Ingredient Snack Taking the Internet by Storm

    "It’s a solid 10 out of 10."

  • 14 Ingredient Swaps That Will Make Potato Salad So Much Better

    We're of the opinion that potato salad needs a little revamp. One of the easiest ways to freshen this dish up is to hit it with some ingenious recipe swaps.

  • The Mistake You're Making When Preparing Bacon In The Microwave

    Microwaving bacon is quick and convenient. However, there is one mistake you're probably making that's keeping this breakfast staple from being its best.

  • Five stars for restaurant that served up "traditional and delicious" food

    Isle of Wight food reviewers Matt and Cat pay a visit to Ganders in St Helens to sample dishes from its menu.

  • Gogglebox: Pete reveals his girlfriend is 'doing his head in'

    Gogglebox's Pete Sandiford tells his sister Sophie Sandiford that his girlfriend has been 'doing his head in'.

  • I cooked meatballs in 4 different appliances, and I won't use my air fryer again

    I tried cooking frozen, premade meatballs with my air fryer, microwave, oven, and stovetop to see which appliance works best for the side dish.

  • Half of Brits admit binning food in secret from partners as households waste up to £500 a year

    The average British household squanders up to £480 a year on fresh food that goes off quicker than anticipated. Salad, bread, and fruit are the most common culprits in our shopping baskets and often find themselves in the bin. Research showed that three in five people (72 per cent) are left feeling guilty when food goes past its best, with nearly half (44 per cent) of those spoken to admitting they even hide sell-by dates and expired food from their partner. Conscious of waste, a surprising 1 in 3 Brits (34 per cent) admit they will regularly turn down dates with friends because they're worried about their food going off at home. This has sparked major FOGO (Fear Of Going Off), with more than half (59 per cent) of Brits admitting to worrying about their food going off every week, according to a new study by Ocado, which spoke to 2,000 adults. The online supermarket has a Fresh+ Promise that ensures customers' food is as fresh as it can be, offering a refund if customers aren't happy. To reassure Brits about the shelf-life of their food and help combat FOGO, Ocado has teamed up with Instagram chef Alfie Steiner, @alfiecooks, who said, "Nothing compares to fresh produce. And it's not only about the great taste, it's knowing you can rest easy and enjoy planning how to cook with it, because your food isn't rapidly wilting away. "FOGO is real, and according to Ocado's research, many of us experience it. I want to help people fight the fear, so they can experience all the joy of super fresh produce, without the worry that they're cooking against the clock." Frustration over expiration dates is helping to fuel FOGO, with over half of Brits (64%) saying they are often disappointed with how long their fresh food lasts. What's more, over a third of Brits (36%) say they have to make return visits to the shops due to their produce going off quicker than expected, with the most common culprits being salad leaves (43%), bread (34%) and soft fruits (33%). Laura Harricks at Ocado added, ''We know how frustrating it can be when food goes off before you were expecting; it can throw meal plans out the window and as this study reveals, social plans and money too! We want to help the nation fight against FOGO and, with the Ocado Fresh+ Promise, give people peace of mind, so they can spend a little less time worrying about the food in their fridge and more time enjoying it." Ocado's Fresh+ Promise ensures customers' food is delivered straight to the door with no supermarket detour. That means food arrives as fresh as they'd expect, and then some. And that goes for fruit and veg, as much as bread and milk, helping plan ahead for next week's lunches. And as a promise is a promise, if customers still aren't 100% happy, they can sort a no-quibbles refund via the Ocado app.

  • How To Cook Elderberries So They're Safe To Eat

    Elderberries have the potential to be poisonous, but it's rather easy to make them safe to eat, and they even have health benefits when properly prepared.

  • Avoid Overusing This Spice When Making Indian Food

    There are a handful of spices that we're used to tasting in common Indian fare, but celebrity chef Varun Inamdar says not to go too far with this one.

  • 8 Frozen Foods You Should Be Buying At Target

    Target offers tons of different frozen foods. Which ones are the best? We think these 8 options are the ones that deserve a spot on your Target shopping list.

  • 11 Of The Unhealthiest Store-Bought Tuna Salads You'll Find

    Store-bought tuna salads can be deceptively high in sodium, saturated fats, and added sugars -- which brands should you avoid adding to your grocery cart?

  • 13 Ingredients Chefs Use In Tuna Salad Instead Of Mayo

    Expert chefs have shared their insights on what they believe to be some of the best substitutes for mayo in tuna salad. Here are 13 mayonnaise alternatives.

  • This Colchester shop will change your opinion on jacket potatoes forever

    A JACKET potato may not be everyone's favourite meal, but after going to this Colchester shop, I'm sure your opinion will be changed.