Boodle’s Orange Fool

Boodle's orange fool
Use proper cake rather than trifle sponges for the Boodle’s orange fool - Liz & Max Haarala Hamilton

This dish is from an old London gentlemen’s club called Boodle’s. It opened its doors in 1762 and still exists, though I can’t say when this dish, a kind of cross between a trifle and a posset, was first served. It’s easy to make – a great standby dessert – but use proper cake rather than trifle sponges.

Plus setting 

Overview

Prep time

20 mins

Serves

6 -8

Ingredients

  • 250g orange or lemon sponge (plain, not drizzle cake), homemade or shop-bought, sliced (I used a Waitrose lemon loaf)

  • 3 tbsp marmalade

  • 3 tbsp orange liqueur (or 3 tbsp orange juice)

  • 2 oranges, segmented, plus the zest and juice of 1 orange

  • zest and juice of 1 lemon

  • 25g caster sugar

  • 450ml double cream

  • 50g flaked almonds, toasted

Method

Step 1

Put the slices of cake in a trifle bowl or individual glasses, with the marmalade spread between them (as you would do when making a trifle) and drizzle with the 3 tbsp of liqueur or orange juice, or a mixture. Lay the orange segments on top.

Step 2

Add the zests and juices of both the orange and lemon to a bowl with the 25g of caster sugar and whisk together until dissolved.

Step 3

In a separate large bowl, lightly whip 450ml of cream until it just holds soft peaks, then gradually beat in the sweetened zests and juices. Spoon or pipe over the sponge.

Step 4

Cover and chill for at least 3 hours to firm up slightly.

Step 5

Scatter with the flaked almonds just before serving.