WordPress.org bans WP Engine, blocks it from accessing its resources

Ivan Mehta
Updated ·4-min read
Matt Mullenweg attends TechCrunch Disrupt NY 2014

WordPress drama went up another notch on Wednesday after WordPress.org, the open source web-hosting software, banned hosting provider WP Engine from accessing its resources.

In a post on WordPress.org, WordPress co-creator and Automattic CEO Matt Mullenweg wrote that pending their legal claims, WP Engine will not have access to the platform's resources, such as themes and plug-ins.

"WP Engine wants to control your WordPress experience, they need to run their own user login system, update servers, plugin directory, theme directory, pattern directory, block directory, translations, photo directory, job board, meetups, conferences, bug tracker, forums, Slack, Ping-o-matic, and showcase. Their servers can no longer access our servers for free," he said.

"WP Engine is free to offer their hacked up, bastardized simulacra of WordPress’s GPL code to their customers, and they can experience WordPress as WP Engine envisions it, with them getting all of the profits and providing all of the services," Mullenweg wrote.

As a result of this block, sites using WP Engine's solutions cannot install plug-ins or update their themes.

https://twitter.com/ViewFromTheBox/status/1839046583272485352 https://twitter.com/bgardner/status/1839070322617643212 https://twitter.com/mgeheren/status/1839067797080379552

As several WordPress developers and advocates pointed out, the ban also prevents WP Engine customers from accessing security updates, leaving them vulnerable.

WP Engine acknowledged this issue and said the company is working on a fix.

"WordPress.org has blocked WP Engine customers from updating and installing plugins and themes via WP Admin. There is currently no impact on the performance, reliability, or security of your site, nor does it impact your ability to make updates to your code or content," an update from WP Engine read.

In response to the incident, WP Engine said in a post that Mullenweg had misused his control of WordPress to interfere with WP Engine customers' access to WordPress.org.

"Matt Mullenweg’s unprecedented and unwarranted action interferes with the normal operation of the entire WordPress ecosystem, impacting not just WP Engine and our customers, but all WordPress plugin developers and open-source users who depend on WP Engine tools like ACF," WP Engine said.

https://twitter.com/wpengine/status/1839246341660119287

The WP Engine vs. Automattic fight

It's important to understand that WordPress powers nearly 40% of the websites on the internet through different hosting providers, which include Mullenweg's Automattic and WP Engine. Users can also take the open source project and run the websites themselves, but a lot of people choose to go with plug-and-play solutions.

The fight began last week when Mullenweg criticized WP Engine publicly at a conference and on his blog for profiteering and called it a "cancer to WordPress." He also alleged the company doesn't contribute as much as Automattic does to the WordPress community despite both of them making about a half-billion dollars in revenue annually.

This spurred WP Engine to send a cease-and-desist letter to Mullenweg and Automattic, asking them to withdraw their comments. The letter alleged that Mullenweg and Automattic had threatened to adopt a "scorched earth nuclear approach" if WP Engine did not comply and pay Automattic a percentage of its gross revenue.

In reply, Automattic sent its own cease-and-desist letter to WP Engine, alleging infringement of the WordPress and WooCommerce trademarks.

Separately, the WordPress Foundation, a charity created by Mullenweg to maintain WordPress as an open source project, told TechCrunch that WP Engine has violated its trademarks.

"WP Engine has indeed breached the WordPress Trademark Policy. The Policy states that no one is allowed to use the WordPress trademarks as part of a product, project, service, domain name, or company name. WP Engine has repeatedly violated this policy and the Cease and Desist letter sent to them by Automattic provides examples of some of the many violations," the foundation said in an email.

The policy was updated yesterday to include an example of WP Engine. Notably, the policy doesn't cover "WP" as a trademark.

Hours after banning WP Engine from WordPress.org, Mullenweg wrote on his blog that trademarks are the core issue. He said Automattic has been trying to sign a licensing deal with WP Engine for a long time. He noted that the company offered WP Engine the option to either pay a direct licensing fee or make in-kind contributions to the open source project. However, he didn't clarify what making in-kind contributions would mean.

You can contact this reporter at im@ivanmehta.com or on Signal: @ivan.42

Latest stories

  • Bye, Elon — Bluesky Is Gaining Popularity Post-Election. Here's What You Need To Know.

    The competitor to X, formerly called Twitter, just reached 16 million users this week.

  • ‘I was a firefighter for 35 years – but a pension blunder left me penniless’

    Frank Gallacher worked as a firefighter at Britain’s nuclear weapons headquarters for 35 years.

  • Fibre optic cables should be considered 'critical infrastructure' in Africa, Google says

    African governments should give fibre optic cables greater protection from attacks and harmonize policies around layouts to encourage the development of tech infrastructure, a Google executive said on Thursday. Charles Murito, Google's head of government relations and public policy in Africa, wants fibre classified as critical infrastructure, giving the terrestrial and subsea cables that underpin the continent's communications more protection. Damage caused by criminal syndicates seeking to steal batteries and generators from tower base stations and dig up fibre optic cables has increased significantly in recent years, creating extra costs for network infrastructure providers.

  • Tesla's Chinese EV competitors are racing to build their own Optimus rivals

    EV startup Xpeng unveiled its Iron robot this month, a nearly 6-foot tall robot that the company said was already working in its factories and stores.

  • Google launches Gemini app for iOS worldwide

    On Thursday Google launched a dedicated app for its AI-powered assistant, Gemini, on iOS globally. Until now, iOS users either had to use the Google app or mobile web to chat with the AI technology. The new Gemini iOS app supports text-based prompts in 35 languages.

  • ‘Smart’ devices have serious downsides

    Letter: Dr Jan Udris notes the catastrophic contribution to global warming, and says the more complex technology is, the more likely it is to go wrong

  • Reeves’s tax raid could spell end of the barman

    Rachel Reeves’s £25bn tax raid on businesses could mean last orders for bartenders, industry chiefs have suggested, as higher costs prompt pubs to rely more on apps.

  • Intel is far from becoming the American chipmaking powerhouse the US needs

    Intel is struggling to overcome a series of challenges and establish itself as a globally competitive chipmaker.

  • Pension ‘megafunds’ to be created to boost investment

    Pension “megafunds” are set to be created to help unlock billions of pounds of investment in businesses and infrastructure. Rachel Reeves will use her first Mansion House speech as Chancellor to outline the pensions shake-up. Under the plans, the reforms will be introduced through a new Pension Schemes Bill next year, consolidating defined contribution schemes and pooling assets from 86 local government pension scheme authorities. The Local Government Pension Scheme in England and Wales will manage assets worth around £500 billion by 2030.

  • Three Dorset Homebase stores at risk of closure

    HOMEBASE stores across Dorset are at risk of closure as the struggling business is set for administration.

  • iPhone users could get share of £3billion in iCloud legal battle

    Apple does not allow customers to store or back up all of their phone’s data with a third-party provider

  • Founders warn of hiring freeze ahead of national insurance hike

    A majority of founders are warning they will have to implement a hiring freeze ahead of the employers’ National Insurance Contributions (NICs) increase set to come into effect this spring. The warning signs follow Rachel Reeves’ announcement in the Budget last month of a 1.2 per cent increase to employers’ NICs, taking the total to

  • UK regulator to start in-depth probe into GXO's $962 million Wincanton deal

    GXO outbid CEVA, a unit of French shipping firm CMA CGM, to buy the British logistics firm for 762 million pounds ($962.3 million) in March to expand into the UK's aerospace, utilities, industrial, and healthcare sectors. Wincanton operates in the UK and Ireland and offers supply chain solutions to businesses across sectors.

  • 23-year-old woman awarded prestigious William Morris Craft Fellowship

    A 23-year-old woman has become one of the youngest people to complete a prestigious craft fellowship.

  • Any hope of ‘getting Britain working again’ must not demonise people on welfare

    At the height of the pandemic, the government temporarily paused welfare conditionality, but claimants continued to seek work at just the same level as when conditionality was in place.

  • Russian farmers rush to sell grain to profit from high interest rates

    Russian farmers appear to be changing their habit of withholding excess grain for better times amid low global prices, as high interest rates make it attractive to cash in and deposit money in banks at home, analysts said. The Russian central bank hiked its key interest rate to 21% last month, the highest level in more than 20 years, as it fights inflation in the overheated economy. Many banks are now offering short-term deposits with interest rates of up to 25%.

  • Ford Motor hit with $165 million US penalty over delayed rearview camera recalls

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) -The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration said Thursday Ford Motor has agreed to a $165 million civil penalty after a government investigation found the automaker failed to recall vehicles with defective rearview cameras in a timely manner. Under a consent order that will last at least three years, the No. 2 U.S. automaker must pay $65 million in cash, spend $45 million on advanced data analytics, a new testing facility and other projects and $55 million will be held in abeyance subject to complying with the agreement. NHTSA in August 2021 opened an investigation after Ford in 2020 recalled 620,246 vehicles for a rear camera issue to determine whether the carmaker recalled the vehicles in a timely fashion.

  • KFC sues Church's Chicken over 'original recipe' fried chicken branding

    KFC claims that Church's use of the phrase "original recipe" in its own advertisements "is likely to create confusion in the marketplace.

  • Pension ‘megafunds’: How do they work and is bigger always better?

    Reforms will be introduced under a new Pension Schemes Bill next year, as part of Government plans to boost economic growth.

  • Intel’s Comeback Conundrum: Will INTC Stock Soar or Stumble in 2024?

    Intel (NASDAQ:INTC) used to be the undisputed leader in chip-making. However, the 2020s have not been so kind. AMD started gaining CPU market share against Intel during the pandemic years and they quickly got better–in terms of value–to the point where Intel was in serious danger of losing its CPU market leadership to AMD. It […]