Sam's Club Just Brought Back a Cheesy Fan Favorite for the Holidays

But not everyone is thrilled.

Sam's Club has been rolling out a slew of holiday-inspired items that shoppers have eagerly added to their carts. From Garrett Gingerbread Popcorn to the Colossal Candy-Filled Vanilla Cupcake, the warehouse chain is clearly in the festive spirit.

Now, another popular item has returned to shelves—this one more savory than sweet—but it’s receiving mixed reviews.

Sam’s Club Brings Back Member’s Mark Lobster Mac & Cheese

The fan-favorite Lobster Mac & Cheese has officially made its comeback. This indulgent dish features chunks of lobster and cavatappi pasta bathed in a creamy sauce made with five different white cheeses. It’s a holiday side dish that many members remember fondly.

Instagram user @SamsClubLovers shared their excitement, posting, “I am SO excited! Lobster Mac & Cheese is BACK for a limited time! If you didn’t try it last time around, now is your chance!”

While some are eager to snag this seasonal treat, reviews remain divided. Enthusiastic fans praised it with comments like “omg, I would get that in a heartbeat” and “really, really good.”

However, not everyone is sold. “It didn’t have any flavor,” one commenter claimed, adding that the lobster lacked seasoning. Another noted inconsistency in the dish, saying, “There was barely any [lobster], just some sprinkled on top.” A different customer added that the amount of lobster “kind of varies” based on their experience trying it twice.

One point most agree on? The ease of preparation. This makes the dish an excellent addition to a holiday spread. Serving four to six people, it only takes about 40 to 50 minutes in the oven at 375 degrees F (190 degrees C) to heat and serve.

The Member’s Mark Lobster Mac & Cheese is now available at Sam’s Club locations nationwide for a limited time. You can grab it for about $7.98 per pound, but prices can vary depending on your location.