We independently evaluate the products we review. When you buy via links on our site, we may receive compensation. Read more about how we vet products and deals.
Michelle Pfeiffer loves a black turtleneck — we found one like hers that's 'not too tight' at Amazon
Save more than 50% with the on-page coupon and transition into fall in style.
Michelle Pfeiffer is about as glam as you can get without being over-the-top. This Catwoman still purrs, occasionally making us swoon with her makeup-free selfies on Instagram. And if you’ve scrolled through her ‘gram, you may have noticed that she really likes black turtlenecks. Us too! There's just about no single piece so suited to stylishly transitioning into fall. With that in mind, we scoured Amazon for one we think will dress you up without making it look like you tried too hard — you know, just like la Pfeiffer. We struck paydirt with the Merokeety Long Sleeve Turtleneck, and it's on sale for $40.
Simple and sophisticated, the relaxed fit of this turtleneck is just what we need to stay comfortable as we transition into cooler weather.
Why do I need this? 🤔
No one since Audrey Hepburn has made this wardrobe staple look so alluring — and Pfeiffer’s pullover is just what we need to spruce up our wardrobes as we head into the fall season with a little elegance. Neither too constricting or too chunky, it’s simplicity at its best.
This one is made with a blend of nylon, polyester and viscose for a super soft feel. It's long enough to cover your bum, and it's loose-fitting while being figure-flattering — that's tough for any sweater to do.
What reviewers say 💬
More than 2,000 shoppers are cozying up in this cold weather must-have.
Pros 👍
"I love how this sweater fits!" shared a five-star fan. "It’s super soft and doesn’t swallow me. The arms fit rather than being big and baggy but they don’t squeeze. Seems just right to me. Not too tall and not too tight around the neck yet not baggy. This is my favorite sweater in years. ."
"This sweater is excellent for cold days," another raving reviewer wrote. "It's so warm. It's very soft, really good quality, hangs well. Looks expensive. It did come vacuum sealed so I did have to steam out the creases and wrinkles but that was no problem. I get a lot of compliments on it."
Related this over-the-moon customer: "Very soft has some stretch and is a good length. The neck doesn't make you feel like you are being strangled. It's more of a soft hug. Keeps me very warm but not sweating hot. I've worn mine from early Nov to early Apr. Very flattering. Very soft. I wash mine if cold gentle setting lay it flat to dry and no shrinkage."
"Love this sweater," said this happy shopper. "It's soft, thick, comfy, arms are long enough! The wrists don't flare like it looks in the pic but it's super cute!!"
Cons 👎
"I ordered a large and the size is ok but I was expecting it to be a bit longer and more tunic-length," wrote one reviewer.
"The fabric is very stretchy and seems like it will snag easily," warned one shopper. "I’m keeping it because I still think it will pair well with leggings or skinny jeans but it’s overall not what I hoped for."
Long enough to cover your bum and it's loose-fitting while being figure-flattering, it looks great with jeans or leggings.
More Michelle Pfeiffer-inspired black turtlenecks
Not quite what you're looking for? Here are some of Amazon's most popular black turtlenecks inspired by Michelle Pfeiffer.
Reviewers love how soft, comfortable and flattering this sweater is. No matter which part of the body wearers want to camouflage, this sweater seems to accomplish the goal. More than 6,000 have given it a perfect five-star rating.
"It hangs down and covers my bum," said a fanny-conscious reviewer. "I was initially hesitant to buy it because the image shows it sort of stiff and [that it] might stick out at the sides. It doesn't at all."
This sassy, oversized sweater has a unique eye-catching cut beloved by 20,000 proud owners.
“I hate turtlenecks, but this one is soft, loose and not confining,” said a devotee. “The material is exceptionally soft and forgiving. I wore it yesterday to work with black leggings and knee boots and felt fabulous. I actually love it so much I am washing it now to wear to dinner with my family.”
Shoppers rave about this comfy sweater for its easy fit — the arms are loose, not snug — and flattering cut.
"It’s been quite some time since I’ve owned a turtleneck, and I was a bit nervous about how I would feel this time around," shared one of 13,000 happy shoppers. "I love it! This sweater is very flattering and soft. Would go perfect with a pair of jeans and your favorite boots, or you could dress it up!"
Loved by 14,000 rave reviewers, this oversized sweater falls to the mid-thigh and comes with ... wait for it ... pockets!
"Want to look like you put effort into your style, but it took you five minutes?" asked a five-star fan. "This sweater is amazing — pair it with some leggings, a messy bun and it makes it look like you really have it all together, even though you just rolled out of bed 10 minutes before. It has pockets for when you don't know what to do with your hands, and it has enough bagginess to hide even the biggest lunch stomach or monthly bloat."
If you have Amazon Prime, you’ll get free shipping, of course. Not yet a member? No problem. You can sign up for your free 30-day trial here. (And by the way, those without Prime still get free shipping on orders of $25 or more.)
The reviews quoted above reflect the most recent versions at the time of publication.
Looking for more great Amazon style and beauty deals? Check these out:
Beauty
Nature Well Clinical Retinol Advanced Moisture Cream
$10$25Save $15 with coupon
Revlon One-Step Volumizer Plus 2.0
$36$70Save $34
Style
Brabic Seamless Shapewear Bodysuit
$12$23Save $11
Adidas Athletic Cushioned No-Show Socks, 6 Pairs
$17$22Save $5 with coupon
Merokeety Open-Front Cardigan
$24$58Save $34 with coupon
