39 cancelled Netflix shows that need to be brought back in 2023

It's never fun for fans when the decision is made to pull the plug on a beloved TV show, and although Netflix regularly delivers with its amazing content, we wouldn't be surprised if almost everyone who uses it has had their favourite show cancelled at some point or another.

From period dramas to underappreciated animations, here are the shows Netflix should absolutely bring back…

1899

1899 has not been renewed for a second season - and fans are devastated. The show's co-creator Baran bo Odar confirmed the news on Instagram. "With a heavy heart we have to tell you that 1899 will not be renewed," he wrote. "We would have loved to finish this incredible journey with a second and third season as we did with Dark. But sometimes things don’t turn out the way you planned. That's life."

WATCH: 1899 was cancelled after one season

Warrior Nun

It was back in December 2022, that Netflix first confirmed Warrior Nun's cancellation, after just two seasons. Creator Simon Barry confirmed the news on Twitter, writing: "I've just found out that @netflix will not be renewing #WarriorNun. My sincere appreciation to all the fans who worked so hard to bring awareness to this series, and for the love you showed me, the cast and the whole production team. It was a privilege to be a part of this."

Cobra Kai

Josh Heald, Jon Hurwitz and Hayden Schlossberg confirmed that "bittersweet" news that Cobra Kai would conclude with season six. In a letter to fans, they wrote: "Reacquainting the world with the Karate Kid universe has been our humble honour.

"It has enabled us to play sensei, expanding the original storylines and birthing a new generation of underdogs. We’ve never once taken this opportunity for granted. Our Day 1 goal with Cobra Kai has always been to end it on our terms, leaving the Valley in the time and place we’ve always imagined. While this may be a bittersweet day for the fandom, the Miyagiverse has never been stronger… We hope to be telling more Karate Kid stories with you down the line because as we all know: Cobra Kai never dies."

First Kill

Variety confirmed that Netflix has cancelled the beloved teen drama. First Kill was a hugely popular vampire show and landed on the streaming platform in early June to much praise from fans - but the show reportedly has been shelved due to viewing numbers. Dominic D. Goodman, who played Apollo in the show, tweeted about the cancellation, writing: "To all the First Kill fans; I have nothing but love for every single one of you! Thank you all for taking the show in as your own, seeing you all feel seen made all the hard work and hours worth it til the next project."

Riverdale

Although it was ultimate the CW's decision, Riverdale has always aired in the UK on Netflix, and has confirmed that the seventh season will be it's last. The show is based on the Archie Comics and stars the likes of KJ Apa, Lili Reinhart, Camila Mendes, Cole Sprouse, Madelaine Petsch, Mädchen Amick, Casey Cott, Charles Melton and Vanessa Morgan. Taking to Twitter to discuss the news, one fan wrote: "Why would they cancel the greatest show of all time?"

MORE: 19 returning TV shows we're seriously excited for this year

READ: 10 most exciting Netflix shows and films coming out in 2023

The Babysitter's Club

The streaming giant will not be ordering a third season of the show, which is based on the bestselling novels by Ann M. Martin and follows seven close-knit friends as they start their own babysitting business. Fans have been quick to turn to social media to vent their frustrations. One dissatisfied viewer tweeted: "Netflix cancelled The Baby-Sitters Club?!! Are you kidding me? I feel like every time I fall in love with a show on Netflix, they cancel it."

Grand Army

Much to the disappointment of its passionate fanbase, Grand Army isn't returning for a second season. The show's first season, which was released in October of last year, followed five students at a large high school in Brooklyn and chronicled their "take on our chaotic world as they fight to succeed, survive, wild out, break free and seize the future." 

The Baby-Sitter's Club

The streaming giant will not be ordering a third season of the show, which is based on the bestselling novels by Ann M. Martin and follows seven close-knit friends as they start their own babysitting business. Fans have been quick to turn to social media to vent their frustrations. One dissatisfied viewer tweeted: "Netflix cancelled The Baby-Sitters Club?!! Are you kidding me? I feel like every time I fall in love with a show on Netflix, they cancel it."

Archive 81

Netflix will not be renewing the creepy psychological thriller series Archive 81, despite it being hugely popular among viewers and critics alike. Needless to say, fans are not pleased, with one person writing: "Y'all really had to cancel #archive81, one of the greatest shows in a long time that I only learned about because it was consistently in your Top 10? I've been subscribed since 2011, but this broke me. I'm done. I'm out." 

Gentefied

Gentefied, which debuted on the streaming platform in 2020, will not be back for a third series, according to Variety. The show, which was produced by Ugly Betty star America Ferrera, is a comedy-drama that followed the lives of three Mexican-American cousins as they tackle issues such as gentrification, borders, and family life, all while trying to save their relative's taco shop from folding.

Narcos: Mexico

The series recently released season three, which has been confirmed to be the show's last. Chatting about why the decision was made, co-creator Carlo Bernard told The Hollywood Reporter: "I saw this season as an origin story of the modern world that we live in. For me, it felt like bringing the show up to that spot where we now recognise, for better or for worse, made sense as a place to stop it... Not to say that other stories wouldn't be compelling going forward. But to me, stopping at the moment where we had delivered the world that we now live in today made sense, thematically and narratively."

Bonding

onding followed a New York City grad student who enlists her friend to help her to moonlight as a dominatrix. The show lasted for two seasons, with the second instalment landing on the streaming service in January - but a third season was sadly not meant to be.

Country Comfort

Creature Comfort follows an aspiring country singer who takes on a nanny job for a handsome cowboy named Beau and his five children. Fans were disappointed that it was cancelled after one season, with one writing: “Super bummed that Netflix cancelled #CountryComfort. It was super adorable and something I could watch with my kids.” Another added: “NO NO NOO I really needed a second season of #countrycomfort. Can’t another platform pick it up?!”

The Society

The future of the dystopian teen drama about a group of high school students trapped in their town with no adults and no means of escape wasn't meant to be. The Hollywood Reporter's sources claim that unexpected budget increases due to the pandemic - among other reasons - meant that Netflix cancelled the series.

MORE: 29 amazing films based on true stories

Speaking about his disappointment at the news, showrunner Chris Keyser told Variety: "We spent the last bunch of months getting ready to go back again, dealing with all the COVID protocols. And then I got a call from Netflix saying, 'We have made this decision.' It was obviously pretty upsetting and abrupt."

Atypical

Despite having a firm fan following, Atypical has been given a fourth and last season from the streaming platform. At the time, Netflix tweeted: "Join Sam on one last expedition. Atypical will return for a fourth and final season. They've brought you laughs, tears, hugs and homies. Now see how the story concludes. Atypical. The final season." While some keen viewers were disappointed, plenty were also relieved that the show had the opportunity to conclude its story.

MORE: Find out what Netflix show you should be watching based on your star sign

I Am Not Okay with This

Although the show received a warm reception, co-creator Jonathan Entwistle opened up about the variety of reasons that it wasn't picked up for season two. Chatting to NME about how the pandemic affected the show's future, he explained: "Netflix was basically saying we’re paying large groups of filmmakers and actors to remain doing nothing. We were locked into I Am Not Okay With This and it looked like it was never going to shoot. 

"I think that one of the problems we faced with I Am Not Okay With This is that in many ways I considered it to be a smaller, niche show and they considered it to be a replacement for Stranger Things. I do think when they were looking at all the finances, the show was more expensive than they figured it was worth doing."

White Lines

According to one of the show's leading stars, crime drama White Lines has not been given the go-ahead for a second instalment. Sharing a photo of his character Marcus, actor Daniel Mays confirmed the sad news on Instagram. "Following the reports in the press over the past couple of days and for all those asking me on here, it’s with a heavy heart I post the #WhiteLines season 2 ship has well and truly sailed," he wrote. "Huge thanks, respect and admiration to @netflix @netflixuk @alexpinaoficial @leftbankpictures and @vancouvermedia_ for the ride of a lifetime."

Shadowhunters

Despite having a very, very dedicated fan base, Shadowhunters was cancelled ahead of its planned fourth series. While the show aired on Freeform in the US, it was available via Netflix in the UK, and the Executive Vice President of Programming and Development Karey Burke opened up about the cancellation during a media lunch, telling Deadline: "We were very happy creatively with it.

"They delivered what the fans wanted... We are very proud of Shadowhunters, a series that broke new ground in the genre world and became a fan-favourite. However, along with our partners at Constantin, we reached the very difficult decision not to renew the show for a fourth season." According to Digital Spy, the show was unable to continue after its production company Constantin Films lost an output deal with Netflix, and as a result was unable to finance another season.

Anne with an E

Although fans were hoping to see more seasons from the popular CBC/Netflix drama Anne with an E, it has been confirmed that the show's third series will be its last. The popular period drama, based on the bestselling book series Anne of Green Gables, follows a plucky orphan with a love of books and nature, who finds a home and family in Green Gables. The executive producer of the show, Moira Walley-Beckett, confirmed the news that the show won't be returning in a heartfelt Instagram post, writing: "Beloved fans & friends of #AWAE, I’m sorry for the sad Netflix/CBC news today. I wish it could be different but it cannot. We have reached the end of the red Green Gables road after 3 wonderful seasons."

Turn Up Charlie

Fans have expressed their disappointed following reports that Idris Elba's Netflix drama, Turn Up Charlie, has been cancelled after just one season. According to the Daily Mirror, the show won't be going ahead after the Luther actor and Netflix didn't see eye to eye on the future of the show. Viewers were quick to share their reaction, with one writing: "Just heard about @idriselba 's #TurnUpCharlie being cancelled. Hey, since it's my 50th #Birthday, can you uncancel it for my present @netflix?"

V-War

V-Wars, starring Ian Somerhalder, was shelved early in 2020. The creator of the show, Jonathan Maberry, tweeted about the cancellation, writing: "So, I guess the bad news is already out. #vwars." He added that he hadn't been informed that Netflix had made the decision until he had seen an article about it. Replying to a fan who asked him about the cancellation, he wrote: "We're all finding out via the news story," adding that it was a surprise as they "were number #1 in so many global markets".

October Faction

Sadly for fans, the monster drama was cancelled after lukewarm reviews, receiving just 33% positive reviews from critics on Rotten Tomatoes. According to the VP of content, Cindy Holland, cancellations also depend on how much the show costs to make in relation to how many views it is getting. She spoke at the Code Conference: "The basic calculation is, how much viewing are we getting for what it costs? We also look at, is it reaching different audiences. Is it gaining critical acclaim? Is it doing something for us as a business that we like?"

Messiah

The controversial show was cancelled after one season, with star Wil Traval writing on Instagram: "It’s a very sad day today. I have just received news from Netflix that there will be no season 2 of #messiah. I wanted to say to all the fans thank you for your support and love. I wish things were different.” According to Variety, Netflix was reluctant to renew the show for a second season due to the large amount of filming locations around the world, particularly regarding the coronavirus pandemic.

Spinning Out

Despite having an enthusiastic fan base, Netflix has cancelled the popular new drama Spinning Out. The series, which was released on 1 January, follows a young competitive figure skater, Kat Baker, who returns to ice skating following a traumatic fall alongside her new partner, Justin. Keen viewers of the series took to Twitter to persuade Netflix bosses to renew the show, beginning the hashtag '#RenewSpinningOut." Fingers crossed!

Daybreak

The creators of the popular Netflix show Daybreak, which premiered on the streaming service in late 2019, has confirmed that the dark comedy will not be returning for a second season. Co-creator Aron Coleite shared a statement on Twitter with the caption: "I don't even know how to say this, so we prepared a small statement. Love you all. Thank you!" The statement read: "We learned last week that Daybreak will not be returning for a second season.

"We’re so sorry we couldn’t share it with you sooner but also grateful that we got to hang out in these last few live tweet sessions with all of you. Thank you for picking up what we put down, for running with it in all of your amazing, weird, monstrous ways and for being such an important part of this show and our experience making it. No one is as heartbroken as we are that we can’t share more of this ride with you. But we’re so grateful to have gotten to bring it this far."

Mystery Science Theatre 3000

Mystery Science Theatre 3000 was cancelled after just two series. The series, which follows a host and his robot friends as they watch a different film in every episode, had a dedicated cult following. The show's star Jonah Ray Rodriguez took to Twitter to announce that it wouldn't return to Netflix.

Referencing the other shows that Netflix has cancelled, he wrote: "So, Netflix decided to not do another season of MST3K. We are off to Get Down in Lilyhammer while the OA helps us take it One Day at a Time. We will be in group therapy with Tuca & Bertie, Jessica Jones, & Lady Dynamite. The sessions will be run by Gypsy (w/ Naomi Watts)."

Soundtrack

After just one season of the romantic musical drama, Variety confirmed that Netflix has cancelled the all-singing show, which shares love stories from a group of different people living in LA.

BoJack Horseman

This was a shocker! BoJack Horseman is finishing after season six, and Aaron Paul revealed that it was the streaming service's decision to end the much-loved comedy. Speaking about the cancellation on Twitter, the Breaking Bad star wrote: "We had a wonderful time making BoJack. Couldn't be more proud. Fell in love with these characters just like everyone else did but sadly Netflix thought it was time to close the curtains and so here we are. They gave us a home for 6 beautiful years. Nothing we could do about it."

Seven Seconds

The anthology series Seven Seconds, which followed racial tensions in the US after a white police officer accidentally critically injure a black teenager, was cancelled after just one series, despite a star performance from Emmy-award winner, Regina King.

At the time, the VP of Original Content at Netflix, Cindy Holland, said: "We loved working with Veena, Regina and the cast and crew of Seven Seconds. Together they created a compelling, timely and relevant crime drama. The first season is a complete, stand-alone story that we are proud to feature on Netflix for years to come."

American Vandal

Despite being much loved by the people who actually watched it, unfortunately, the mockumentary series just didn't get the viewership and was cancelled after two seasons. At the time, Netflix released a statement which read: "We're very grateful to the creators, writers, cast and crew for bringing their innovative comedy to Netflix, and to the fans and critics who embraced its unique and unconventional humour." Speaking about its cancellation, one fan wrote: "Imagine making 13 Reasons Why season 3 but not American Vandal season 3? Bruh."

The OA

The strange and unique story about a missing blind woman, who is found with her eyesight back, had viewers talking – both good and bad. Unfortunately, the show was cancelled after just two series, and ahead of completing the story arc.

Creator Brit Marling posted about the situation on Instagram, writing: "Zal and I are deeply sad not to finish this story. It's been an intense journey for everyone who worked on and cared about this story." Rebel Wilson was among those to mourn the loss of the show, and commented on Brit's post: "Congrats on such an awesome, imaginative and creative show." Emma Roberts added: "I'm devastated."

Santa Clarita Diet

Despite having a passionate fan base, Drew Barrymore's zombie drama just didn't make the cut, and Netflix confirmed they were cancelling the show after its third series. The co-creators Victor Fresco and Tracy Katsky said: "Netflix took a chance on this odd show and for that we will always be grateful. They were supportive, ever-positive, and appreciative of our work.

"Until about noon today. Still, they were just one phone call away from being a perfect studio. Not bad. Everything ends. This was a thing. And so it ended." Tracy told CNN: "They called us with the news yesterday. We are all so sad. We have loved making it so much."

Sense8

Fans were so outraged when Sense8 was cancelled after its second season – with Netflix's vice president Cindy Holland explaining to Radio Times that "if you don't have the viewership showing up to justify the expense of the series, you're going to want to end it" – that Netflix ended up relenting and giving the show a two-hour finale episode to wrap everything up.

At the time, the show's co-creator Lana Wachowski posted a letter to fans: "Improbably, unforeseeably, your love has brought Sense8 back to life… It is my great pleasure as well as Netflix's… to announce that there will be another two hour special released next year. Thank you all. Now let's go find out what happens to Wolfgang."

One Day at a Time

Speaking about season four, Netflix said: "We've made the very difficult decision not to renew One Day at a Time for a fourth season. The choice did not come easily — we spent several weeks trying to find a way to make another season work but in the end simply not enough people watched to justify another season."

Travelers

Eric McCormack confirmed that Travelers wouldn't be renewed for a fourth season. Posting on Twitter, he said: "A lot of you have been asking about the possibility of a Season 4, but many of you have been saying, 'Look, if this is it, what a moving and surprising and profound ending it is.' Well I'm afraid it is. Who knows what the future holds but Travelers programme one as we call it is complete."

Designated Survivor

The popular political drama was cancelled in July 2019 after initially being saved by Netflix for a third season. Netflix released a statement which read: "We are proud to have offered fans a third season of Designated Survivor, and will continue to carry all three seasons for years to come. We're especially thankful to star and executive producer Kiefer Sutherland, who brought passion, dedication and an unforgettable performance as President Kirkman." Kiefer seemed happy to let the show go, saying: "I think it's time for us all to go and find something new to do."

The Good Cop

Sadly for Josh Groban, who played a straight-laced detective who had to deal with his rule-breaking father, The Good Cop was cancelled after just one series. In a statement to Variety, Netflix said: "The Good Cop will not return for a second season. We're grateful to creator Andy Breckman and his fellow producers, writers, the incredible crew and especially stars Tony Danza and Josh Groban for bringing this classic odd couple father-son story to Netflix."

The Punisher and Jessica Jones

After Iron Fist, Daredevil and Luke Cage were cancelled in a cull of Marvel TV shows, it seemed hardly surprising when The Punisher and Jessica Jones followed suit, despite nearly all of the shows (Iron Fist excluded) garnering positive reviews from critics and fans.

Speaking about cancelling the two shows, Netflix said: "Marvel's The Punisher will not return for a third season on Netflix. Showrunner Steve Lightfoot, the terrific crew, and exceptional cast including star Jon Bernthal, delivered an acclaimed and compelling series for fans, and we are proud to showcase their work on Netflix for years to come. In addition, in reviewing our Marvel programming, we have decided that the upcoming third season will also be the final season for Marvel's Jessica Jones.

"We are grateful to showrunner Melissa Rosenberg, star Krysten Ritter and the entire cast and crew, for three incredible seasons of this groundbreaking series, which was recognized by the Peabody Awards among many others. We are grateful to Marvel for five years of our fruitful partnership and thank the passionate fans who have followed these series from the beginning."

Jessica Jones star Krysten Ritter shared a snap from the last read-through for the show, and wrote: "The final season of #JessicaJones is coming later this year and I am proud of how we complete JJ's journey. I can't wait for you all to see it."

Friends from College

The director of the comedy-drama Friends from College, Nicholas Stoller, announced the news that the comedy was cancelled in a short but sweet message which read: "Friends from College will not be returning for a third season. Thanks to everyone who watched it. Happy Presidents' Day!" Fans were unsurprisingly disappointed, with one writing: "This really and truly SUCKS! This was a clever show that was able to funny and dramatic at the same time. Netflix used to give us something different but now it's letting some of us down with mediocrity."

Tuca & Bertie

Following the popularity of shows like BoJack Horseman and Big Mouth, it seemed that this animated series about the friendship between two bird women would be a slam dunk. However, it appears season two wasn't to be.

The creator, Lisa Hanawalt, took to Twitter to express her disappointment, writing: "Everyone is still glowing over the reviews and articles and feedback. T&B is critically acclaimed and has repeatedly been called one of the best new shows of the year… Best of all, I still get daily messages and tweets from viewers who connect personally to the characters and stories. The birdsona & plantsona fan art is SO incredible, are you kidding me!

"And the show is still being discovered by new fans every day! None of this makes a difference to an algorithm, but it's important to me and the way I want to continue making art in this world. Thank you to everyone who loves and supports T&B, and to everyone who was comforted and felt like this show gave you a voice. I'm hopeful we can find a home for Tuca & Bertie to continue their adventures."

Like this story? Sign up to our newsletter to get other stories like this delivered straight to your inbox.