Netflix's You viewers point out Lady Phoebe plot hole in season 4

Dusty Baxter-Wright
·2-min read

You season four might've come to an end with part two landing on Netflix last week [8th March], but viewers still have a big unanswered question around Lady Phoebe and Joe Goldberg/Jonathan Moore.

*Spoilers* The You season four part two finale revealed Joe Goldberg was in fact the Eat The Rich Killer, with Rhys Montrose acting as a figment of his imagination, after the psychopath failed to reinvent himself or shake his murderous ways.

The final episode saw him returning to New York with Kate, seemingly outrunning his dark past, before viewers join Lady Phoebe teaching English in Asia. While both characters appear to get their happy ending, there is one big unanswered question fans are pointing out.

netflix's you viewers point out lady phoebe plot hole in season 4
Netflix

In the first episode, Joe manages to infiltrate Phoebe's wealthy London friendship group, joining them on a night out at a posh members club. What what exactly did he say to her to make her warm to him so much?

As one fan put it, "BUT THE REAL MYSTERY IS WHAT JOE SAID TO LADY PHOEBE #YouSeason4 #YouNetflix"

Another said, "I'm glad the shows is over and I'm fairly satisfied with the ending. But imma need a whole other season Netflix to find out what this mf Joe said to Phoebe in order to infiltrate her friend group of millionaires. #YouNetflix #YouSeason4 #YOU"

While a third added, "WHAT DID JOE SAY TO PHOEBE WHEN HE WAS DRUNK???? #YouNetflix" and "What do you think Joe told Lady Phoebe that first night? #YouNetflix"

"@YouNetflix@netflix We demand to know what Joe told Lady Phoebe to change her world #YouNetflix"

We need answers.

You season 4 part 1 and 2 is now streaming on Netflix.

You Might Also Like

Latest stories

  • Watch: ‘Cretin’ leaps from Venice roof into canal wearing just boxer shorts

    A tourist who dived from the roof of a Venice palazzo into a canal has been described by the mayor of the World Heritage city as “a cretin”.

  • Good Morning Britain star Ranvir Singh brushes off criticism over relationship age gap: ‘People are obsessed’

    Singh is in a relationship with Louis Church, a producer she met on ‘Strictly Come Dancing’

  • Brooklinn Khoury Claps Back at Critics of Her Reconstructed Nose: 'Matches Perfectly with My Face'

    The pro skateboarder, 23, raved that her doctor did “such a good job” with her nose surgery after she was attacked by a pit bull in November 2020

  • Singer Explains Why She “Butchered” UK National Anthem In Front Of Thousands Of Football Fans

    A singer has apologised for “butchering” the British national anthem at an England football match on Thursday evening. Italian-American singer Ellynora had been asked to perform God Save the King before the kick-off of the European Championship qualifier match in Napoli. However, she appeared to have trouble with the song, singing off-key, repeating the first […]

  • Dua Lipa dons tiny floral-print bikini for lush island vacation

    Dua Lipa, the queen of travel and Instagram photo dumps, did not disappoint her fans as she shared a series of captivating snapshots from her recent Jamaican vacation. The Levitating singer, who also has a newsletter and podcast about travel, showcased her exquisite vacation wardrobe while enjoying the picturesque island.On Thursday, the 26-year-old posted a carousel of images that documented her adventures on the island, from beach days and authentic Jamaican cuisine to her stylish outfits. Dua

  • Emma Willis pens cheeky message for husband Matt following baby bump photos

    Emma Willis could not be more loved up with her husband of 14 years, Matt Willis and on Thursday, the star had a cheeky message for her beau. Taking to her Instagram account, the TV presenter, 47, reshared a fabulous photo of Matt posing against a dramatic red backdrop which he posted to reveal that he and his former band Busted are reuniting to mark 20 years of the band. Emma and Matt married in 2008 Emma simply penned: "Fit," alongside the image of her husband who looked incredibly dapper in a

  • Dianne Buswell shows off incredibly toned legs in tiny skort for romantic outing

    Dianne Buswell looked sensational on Friday when she was spotted posing up a storm in a fabulous skort ahead of a romantic outing with her beau, Joe Sugg, 31. Taking to her Instagram account, the professional dancer, 33, shared a carousel of ten loved-up photos. The featured snap captured the flame-haired beauty showing off her impressively toned legs in a black and white patterned skort which she paired with chunky Doc Martins and a chic powder blue coat. Dianne and Joe matched for their outing

  • Ruth Langsford dazzles skin tight skinny jeans for special birthday celebration

    Ruth Langsford looked sensational on Monday, when she was spotted looking ultra glamorous in a pair of slick skinny jeans for her special birthday lunch. Taking to her Instagram account with an exciting video, the former Good Morning Britain star, 63, was a vision in her all-black ensemble which featured a chic silk shirt and stylish leather jacket. In the clip, Ruth and her friends could be seen wining and dining with her friends at James Martin's brand new Cotswold's restaurant, The Lygon Arms

  • Johnny Depp shuns LA for quieter life in Somerset at his £13m estate which allows him to ‘just be me’

    The Pirates of the Caribbean actor, 59, bought the 850-acre West Country estate in 2014

  • Did Mike Tindall visit Prince Harry during surprise California trip?

    Mike Tindall has been enjoying sunnier climates in Los Angeles, California, this week. The former England rugby player was spotted walking along 3rd Street Promenade in Santa Monica and was pictured shopping in a number of retail outlets alongside DIY SOS presenter, Nick Knowles. But royal fans will know that Santa Monica is close to the home of Prince Harry and Meghan Markle. While Mike was in town, he was located a half hour's drive from where the Duke and Duchess of Sussex live in Montecito,

  • Helen Skelton shows off incredible waistline in vibrant spring two-piece

    As a BBC star, Helen Skelton knows how to dazzle when it comes to a charismatic TV appearance, and her latest post on Thursday saw her looking sensational in another killer look. Taking to her Instagram feed, the Countryfile presenter, 39, was a vision as she showed off her incredible waistline in a beautiful pink matching set in a fun reel from her time on BBC's Morning Live which you can see for yourself in the video below. WATCH: Helen Skelton dazzles in beautiful pink co-ord for fun video Th

  • Frida Redknapp stuns as she dons daring shoulder-baring look

    Frida Redknapp is one glamorous woman, and she loves a daring look, something she proved on Friday with her latest photoshoot. The blonde beauty looked absolutely spectacular as she donned an elegant suit-dress, which came in the colour-blocking combination of black and white. The outfit looked beautiful on the star, but she added that extra touch by baring her shoulder in the look, allowing the sleeve to partially fall down her arm. WATCH: Jamie Redknapp's wife Frida shows off petite physique d

  • Mike Tindall enjoys surprise California trip – see all the photos

    Mike Tindall has been enjoying some quality time in California recently, but he surprised fans when it was revealed that he was joined by DIY SOS presenter Nick Knowles. The pair were shopping for gifts on the 3rd Street Promenade in Santa Monica, which is only an hour and a half's drive away from Prince Harry and Meghan Markle in Montecito. Mike and Nick were seen making the most of the warm weather in the Californian city with Mike wearing a burgundy shirt and his companion rocking a similar g

  • Rose Ayling-Ellis inundated with support after frustrating incident

    Rose Ayling-Ellis has been inundated with support following an incident which left her feeling somewhat annoyed. Taking to Instagram on Friday, the 28-year-old - who made history with her Strictly Come Dancing win back in 2021 - revealed she wasn't impressed when she was forced to segregate from other guests at a film screening. One of the images Rose shared on Friday from the premiere At the premiere for Dungeons & Dragons, Rose explained how she and other deaf guests were ushered into a separa

  • Prince Harry and Meghan's son Archie might attend King Charles' coronation for this reason

    There has been much talk over the possible attendance of the Duke and Duchess of Sussex at King Charles III's coronation. With that, many are speculating whether their children, Prince Archie, three, and 21-month-old Princess Lilibet may make a surprise appearance. Prince Harry addressed the matter of his presence in his ITV interview with Tom Bradby earlier this year – see what he had to say in the video below. Although Lilibet may be deemed too young, it's highly likely that their son Archie m

  • Samantha Hanratty & Christina Ricci Slay for 'Yellowjackets,' Plus Elton John, The Biebers & More

    From Hollywood to New York and everywhere in between, see what your favorite stars are up to

  • Princess Beatrice stuns in silky red dress on Princess Eugenie's birthday night out

    Princess Beatrice was pictured with her family for a night of celebrations in honour of Princess Eugenie's birthday on Wednesday night. The royal, who was photographed without her sister, looked beautiful in what appeared to be a bold red outfit in silk, which she layered with a black coat to stay warm. Princess Beatrice and her husband Edoardo attended Eugenie's birthday celebrations Beatrice's husband Edoardo Mapelli Mozzi was also pictured in the taxi, looking smart in a navy suit. The party

  • Pregnant Laura Anderson’s ex Gary Lucy reveals gender of their baby leaving her ‘really upset’

    A source claims that the ex Hollyoaks actor shared the gender of his and the former Love Island star’s unborn baby ‘without getting her consent’

  • Khloé and Kim Kardashian Snuggle Up in Coordinating Swimsuits: 'Kiki and Koko Take Cabo'

    We can thank Kylie Jenner for these stunning pics

  • Working mother TikTok star Jehane Thomas dies after weeks of complaining of severe migraines

    Jehane Thomas, 30, died just days after sharing a photograph of her smiling with her children