During an appearance on the Podcrushed podcast co-hosted by You star Penn Badgley, The Good Place actress revealed that she was once offered an opportunity to audition for the series but she turned it down because she knew her role would require intimate scenes. "I was supposed to audition for the most recent season of your show. My character was supposed to be quite sexy, and I pulled out of the audition, because I am so shy about anything sexy that I can't.”