Love Island is expriencing a backlash after it was revealed that former contestant Adam Collard will return to the show this week.
Collard, who was part of the season 4 cast in 2018, was so controversial during his time on the series that charity Women’s Aid issued a statement on “gaslighting and emotional abuse”.
The personal trainer, from Newcastle, was widely criticised for his treatment of fellow contestant Rosie Williams.
The series saw Collard and Williams get into a heated argument after Williams accused him of ditching her for newcomer Zara McDermott.
In response, Collard told Williams she had “pushed him away” by showing signs of jealousy towards Zara.
Does no one else remember that domestic abuse charities had to issue warnings RE Adam’s behaviour during his series? I’m all for drama but this feels icky to me #LoveIsland
— Natalie Wilson (@NatalieWilson93) July 11, 2022
In a statement, Women’s Aid said Collard’s behaviour towards Williams was indicative of emotional abuse.
“On the latest series of Love Island, there are clear warning signs in Adam’s behaviour,” the statement said.
“In a relationship, a partner questioning your memory of events, trivialising your thoughts or feelings, and turning things around to blame you can be part of pattern of gaslighting and emotional abuse.”
Some social media users have criticised ITV’s decision to bring back Collard.
“Bringing Adam back despite his gaslighting and manipulation causing charities to use him as an example of abusive relationships is an interesting choice there,” one Twitter user wrote.
Another said: “Does no one else remember that domestic abuse charities had to issue warnings RE Adam’s behaviour during his series? I’m all for drama but this feels icky to me.”
I never want to see the Love Island bosses/producers pretend to care about mental health again. Not after bringing Adam back, the guy that was so bad Women’s Aid had to write a statement on him #LoveIsland
— amber (@amber61783191) July 10, 2022
Earlier this year, the term gaslighting was used in a published High Court judgement in the family courts for the first time, leading human rights barrister Charlotte Proudman, who represented a woman in the case, to say that the judge’s use of the term gives it “legitimacy” and “credibility”.
She added that users have long been “warping victim’s realities” but there had been no legal term to highlight this.
“For too long abusers have distorted victims’ realities and there has been no legal word or concept to expose it. Finally, we have one: gaslighting,” she said.
The term gaslighting has been increasingly used in recent years, applied to everything from behaviour of reality stars to government policy.
What does gaslighting mean?
The term “gaslighting” originates from the 1944 film Gaslight, an adaptation of Patrick Hamilton’s 1938 play Gas Light, in which a man manipulates his wife into believing she has lost her grip on reality, in order to scam her out of her inheritance.
“This term has now been used to describe a set of psychological manipulative behaviours, to get the person being gaslit to doubt their own reality,” Counselling Directory member Thalia Joyner explains.
According to the Oxford English Dictionary, to “gaslight” someone is to manipulate a person by psychological means into questioning his or her own sanity.
Gaslighting doesn’t just refer to romantic relationships. It can happen with friends and family too.
Is gaslighting a crime?
Gaslighting has been a criminal offence since 2015. The coercive or controlling behaviour offence protects victims who “experience the type of behaviour that stops short of serious physical violence, but amounts to extreme psychological and emotional abuse”.
The offence carries a maximum five-year jail term, a fine or both.
Why is gaslighting harmful?
Gaslighting can cause the victim to feel as if their reality has been distorted and to believe the version of events that the perpetrator is telling them even when these events aren’t true. This can be harmful to a person’s mental health.
“All forms of gaslighting cause feelings of confusion and powerlessness, it causes trauma, anxiety, panic and depression,” Joyner says.
She adds that there are various forms of gaslighting, including lying and toxic amnesia, reality manipulations, scapegoating and coercion.
“Toxic amnesia is a form of gaslighting where the person pretends not to remember events or conversations that does not serve them and also creates chaos, doubt and confusion,” Joyner explains.
“Other forms of gaslighting, often referred to as medical gaslighting, shows up a lot in the lives of people living with chronic health conditions and disability,” she continues. “These people often report having their experiences not taken seriously, told that it’s in their heads, being made to feel they are not trying hard enough or even that they are imagining chronic pain or chronic fatigue.
“This is extremely damaging and denies the experiences of the person. This often leads to a mistrust of professionals, feeling even more isolated and I have heard clients say that they ‘thought they have been going mad’.”
What are examples of gaslighting?
Joyner says that gaslighting is used to “not be held accountable for anything”. Perpetrators will shift the blame to their victims with the “intention to manipulate and control”.
She adds: “It is repeated in many different subtle ways to induce doubt in self, thoughts, feelings and what was said or happened.”
Major signs of gaslighting behaviour include second-guessing yourself constantly, the perpetrator denying your version of events, retelling or twisting events, and insisting you said or did things you know you didn’t do.
According to the National Domestic Violence Hotline in the US, some common gaslighting techniques a perpetrator might use include:
Withholding: Pretends to not understand the victim or refuses to listen to.
Countering: Questions the victim’s memory.
Diverting: Changes subject or questions victim’s thoughts.
Trivialising: Makes the victim’s needs seem unimportant
Denial: Perpetrator will deny things like promises to the victim.
Is gaslighting a form of abuse?
Yes. Gaslighting is a form of emotional abuse which is why it was made a criminal offence.
The term was thrown around during the 2021 Love Island season, where one of the contestants was accused of gaslighting the other.
At the time Women’s Aid issued a response to the behaviour saying it became “increasingly concerned” with what appeared to look like gaslighting, possessiveness, and manipulation.
“This is not what a healthy relationship looks like. These are all tactics used by perpetrators of abuse,” it said in a statement.
Joyner adds that the “emotional and psychological fallout” from this type of abuse can “take the longest to heal from”.
What should you do if you think you, or someone you know, are being gaslighted?
If you think you think you are being gaslighted, it’s important you get the right support. Women can call the free National Domestic Abuse Helpline which is run by Refuge on 0808 2000 247 day or night.
Other avenues are speaking to a doctor, men can call the Men’s Advice Line on 0808 8010 327 or ManKind on 0182 3334 244. Those who identify as LGBT+ can call Galop on 0800 9995 428.
If you are in an emergency, call 999.
To support someone you feel may be being gaslighted, Joyner suggests giving them a safe, non-judgemental and supportive space.
“You might be the first person they have told,” she continues. “Help them write down facts so they have a reference point when they feel confused again. Put it somewhere safe like in a passcode-locked box or keep it for them if it is an abusive relationship.”
If this article has raised any issues for you, please call the National Domestic Abuse Helpline on 0808 2000 247.