Fast fashion retailer Forever 21 regularly faces copyright accusations. One Dallas-based designer wants to do something about that, because he is one of the many creatives who believes he has been ripped off by the retailer.
Charles Smith II, the creative director of high-end label Smith II and S2 by Smith II, first noticed that a bralette designed by Forever 21 looked strikingly similar to one of his Do Not Touch designs after model Rose Acosta posted a video of herself wearing the garment on Instagram.
I love working out and eating well but as women we all are prone to cellulite and stretch marks. @vannabelt reached out to offer me her products and I decided to give them a chance and I LOVE THEM! Nothing wrong with a little help!!! They help take your fitness game to the next level! Keep your curves looking smooth and tone with @vannabelt Ps: the gloves feels amazing ????
A post shared by Rosa Acosta (@rosaacosta) on Mar 3, 2017 at 12:21pm PST
The $3.99 Forever 21 seamless bralette featured the phrase “Do Not Touch,” which is the name of one of Smith’s collections. Smith’s Do Not Touch concept was inspired by three things — police injustice, the personal space and boundaries of a woman, and the phrase as it relates to art in a museum.
Smith tells Yahoo Style that friends and colleagues began sending him direct messages about the Forever 21 bralette, mistaking it for his own design.
Fed up with the retailer ripping off independent designers, Smith posted a photo comparing his products featuring the phrase with Forever 21’s bralette. He also included a lengthy note slamming the retailer in the post.
I was going to keep silent about this and handle it legally but fuck that, @forever21 is a giant corporation that gets over on creating cheaply made designs made out of cheap ass Fabric that in a spin cycle of one wash is over before you even dry it. This fuck company ripped off a concept that I incepted January of 2016, as a designer I research every detail of design or concept that I plan to squeeze throughout the collections I create in variations, @donottouchs2 was was a simple idea that went untapped in both commercial & high fashion and I can honestly say and you can Google "Do Not Touch Fashions" and my shit pops up first. Do Not Touch has helped create scholarship funds for kids in a public school system that was built for them to fail and I created and came up with this collection not only to express but to create positive change through the platform I have in the little way that I can, so when giant companies such as @forever21 blantantly steal your ideas and not ask nor compensate you and let alone steal an idea that also belongs to the youth of our public schools, your not only taking money out of my families mouth but you are also taking dreams away from these kids and your taking money out of there pocket which goes to helping there transition into the next great phase of there lives. So @forever21 I know you think your untouchable you seriously have fucked with the wrong nigga, your lack of common decency shows you don't respect young creatives who are trying to accomplish there dreams with our ideas, and sense you lack decency I also will do what I have to do to make you respect me and every other designer you have stolen ideas that you couldn't incept on your own from. @vidakush @asherahswimwear @kimikouture let's stand together and not let these giant companies or fake websites and IG profiles continue to theft our hard working ideas. #OurIdeasAreWorthSomething
A post shared by Charles Smith II (@smiththe2nd) on Mar 5, 2017 at 3:58pm PST
“I was going to keep silent about this and handle it legally but f*** that, @forever21 is a giant corporation that gets over on creating cheaply made designs made out of cheap ass fabric that in a spin cycle of one wash is over before you even dry it,” he wrote in the caption.
Smith also detailed the amount of research he did before conceptualizing the Do Not Touch design he believes Forever 21 ripped off. He explained to Yahoo Style that he checked out all of major fast fashion retailers before the collection was launched in January of 2016 to ensure his design was authentic.
“As a designer I research every detail of design or concept that I plan to squeeze throughout the collections I create in variations, @donottouchs2 was a simple idea that went untapped in both commercial & high fashion and I can honestly say and you can Google ‘Do Not Touch Fashions’ and my s*** pops up first,” he wrote in his Instagram post.
Smith added that there’s a meaningful reason behind his the Do Not Touch collection, which also compelled him to speak out against the retailer.
“Do Not Touch has helped create scholarship funds for kids in a public school system that was built for them to fail, and I created and came up with this collection not only to express but to create positive change through the platform I have in the little way that I can,” he wrote. “When giant companies such as @forever21 blatantly steal your ideas and not ask nor compensate you — and let alone steal an idea that also belongs to the youth of our public schools — you’re not only taking money out of my [family’s] mouth, but you are also taking dreams away from these kids and your taking money out of [their] pocket, which goes to helping [their] transition into the next great phase of [their] lives.”
Proceeds from items in his Do Not Touch collection — including hats and shirts, as well as a percentage of ticket sale profits from his runway shows — directly fund the scholarships for high school graduates moving on to creative art institutions within the Dallas Independent School District. The brand has already raised $9,000 for the scholarships.
RESTOCK Now Available at: ➖www.smiththesecond.com➖[Link in bio] [[Including @smiththe2nd A/W17 "DELMAR" Runway Presentation Ticket Admission]] @donottouchs2 Dad Hats benefiting D.I.S.D and St. Louis Public Schools for high school graduates moving onto creative art institutions. [FREE SHIPPING]
A post shared by S2 by SMITH II (@donottouchs2) on Feb 12, 2017 at 11:59am PST
Smith says knocking off other designers work has been an issue with Forever 21 for a number of years. “You can’t keep stealing ideas from emerging designers and creatives and get away with it,” he tells Yahoo Style. “They’re deliberately doing it.”
Even though Forever 21 has removed the product from its website, Smith shared that he cares more about the noise he is making about the issue than a potential payoff from the retailer.
“Any other designer is being paid off with a settlement or a gag order, but they can’t say anything after they pay them off,” he says. “Designers don’t really speak out in a sense to fight for this. Even if they gave me a settlement, I’m not even going to take that. It’s not even about the money.”
Smith is urging other designers and creatives to band with him against Forever 21. “This isn’t the first time they’ve done this,” he tells Yahoo Style. “They do it all the time, but somebody has got to be the one that stands up for all of us.” The designer added the hashtag #boycottforever21 to a followup post on the matter.
The designer does plan to take legal action. We have reached out to Forever 21 about the matter and will update you when we hear back.
Read more from Yahoo Style + Beauty: