What to Read Next

Cooking from my cookbook: Chocolate Shortbread success or disaster?

Amanda Keats
11 February 2014

Having the first few things I cooked from 'The Great British Book of Baking' turn out so well gave me the false sense of security with my baking that it was actually really easy. Either that or I had finally discovered my superpower!

Shortbread, especially, looked incredibly easy to make. Throw everything but the butter into a bowl and mix. Add the butter and rub it through with your fingertips until it looks like breadcrumbs. Then cook. Easy!

The reality was not quite that straightforward...

260g plain flour
100g caster sugar
40g cocoa powder
a pinch of sea salt
200g unsalted butter
(Cook at gas 4 for about 25 minutes)


There are often moments, when you're cooking something new, when you stop and think 'hang on, I've missed something'. Rubbing the margarine into flour should (in my head at least) be followed up with adding liquid until it becomes pastry. For shortbread biscuits, though, this is not the case. The mixture is cooked exactly as is - in a breadcrumb-looking mixture of fat and flour. When it was ready, I squashed the mixture into my one and only oven pan and put it in the oven, intrigued as to what it would look like when it came out.

The result:

When I took the mixture out I was quite impressed - it looked great! It felt a little spongy to the touch but as this was the first time I had made shortbread I naively assumed the mixture would settle once it cooled. It wasn't until I had decanted the whole thing out onto a dish and sliced into it that I saw just how undercooked the middle layer was. Clearly, it should have been baked in a much shallower dish than the one I have.

I decided to slice each section through the middle to form much thinner biscuits and put them back in the oven for a few more minutes but sadly by that point the damage had been done. I did manage to eat a couple of the slices, warmed in the microwave and with some yoghurt to soften them up. A better suggestion I was told was to eat them with custard. Regardless, I fear many of these shortbreads may just end up in the bin.

Evidently, some recipes really cannot be adapted to suit your requirements. If I had thought about the depth of the tin I could have simply cooked the mixture in two sittings but instead what I got was something which was at first undercooked, then - after all my meddling - rock hard.

It might be time to buy a second baking dish…

Amanda Keats is a recovering vegetarian who is rediscovering her love of cooking. Follow Amanda Keats on Twitter and Facebook.

More articles by Amanda:

Cooking from my cookbook: Rock Cakes

Unusual veggies and what to do with them

VA Mortgage Rates In 2016

VA Rates as Low as 2.75% (3.028% APR) 15 Year Fixed. Exclusive For Veteran & Military Takes 1 Min!

Stomping Out Burglary, One Home at a Time

After his friends were robbed, an engineer at Harvard discovered a serious problem in the home security industry. So He Built Something New.

Get paid to E*TRADE

Sign up today and claim your reward.

Starwood Credit Card

Earn 25,000 Bonus Starpoints®! Use toward Award Nights or Flights.

Cheap Hotels at Priceline

Best Price Guarantee at Priceline. Over 300,000 Hotels w/Great Prices!

Kid sleep troubles email series for moms

We get it. We’ve been there. Sign up for our email track to learn how to handle kids who won’t go to sleep or won’t stay in bed.

Surprising Rule Helps People In Credit Card Debt

Discover how these federal changes are keeping consumers safe and helping people pay off credit card debt faster.

Banks Are Worried Homeowners Will Do This.

Homeowners are surprised and furious. If you owe less than $625,000 on your home, you better read this.

Insane Navy Seal Flashlight, should it be banned?

The Military has recently released technology that is now available to the public. Get yours before they run out - Limited Supply!

File for nada, zilch, zip.

Prepare, print and e-file your simple federal returns for free.

This $625 Intro Bonus Is Insane

A leading credit card issuer just raised its intro bonus to an industry-leading $500 cash or $625 in travel. And no annual fee the first year.

Some Soups Are Worth Melting For

Find Elsa, Olaf, and all your favorite Frozen characters on Campbell's soup cans in a store near you!

Read This Before You Buy Medigap Plan F

Plan F is the most popular Medicare Supplement plan, but there's another Medigap option you should consider.

Federal Stimulus Cuts Mortage Payments in Half!

Don't make your next mortgage payment until you read this! If you're over 45 years old, you could save $4,010 a year. (It's not what you think!)